I've had pretty rotten luck with e.l.f.'s nail polishes in the past, but I decided to try one more time, and I'm glad I did! I actually like this one! I'm not sure if they've improved the formula for their nail polishes, or if I just got lucky with this one color? It's definitely shiny, but in a sort of muted way.
Yes, it looks super shiny there. Sorry, my flash turned my nails into a disco ball. Anyway, these nail polishes are $2 and currently available in more than 50 shades. Note to self for next time: I want to order Garnet, Glamour Girl, and maybe Pot of Gold.